Great by Choice by Jim Collins

Great by Choice by Jim Collins: Yorkshire Powerhouse Score 9/10

This is another very powerful addition to the Jim Collins stable, as always the theory is based on sound evidence.

Who will gain the most from reading this book?

A business leader who is committed to the growth of a company and not to his career or political power.

Core Content

This book investigates why some companies perform so well in today’s increasingly volatile and uncertain economic environment while their peers often fall by the wayside.

Backed up by rigorous analysis the book identifies a handful of successful companies and then sets out to explain, with empirical evidence, why these companies performed so well in these uncertain times.

The book is structured around 6 main concepts:

The book uses 10Xers (Leaders who strive to grow their business to ten times its size) as exemplars for how we should lead and drive a business.

Concept: 10xer’s lead

  • Great companies (10xers) accept uncertainty but refuse to accept that forces beyond their control will determine their destiny. Instead they work very hard at a clearly defined goal to build up a reservoir of strength (e.g. through cash on balance sheet or reputation in the market)
  • 10xers consistently exhibit three core behaviours to build a reservoir of strength:
    • Fanatic discipline: Consistency of action around clearly defined strategy
    • Empirical creativity: decisions are made from a sound empirical base
    • Productive paranoia: constantly operating with a heightened state of awareness against potential threats

Concept: 20 Mile March

  • 10xers’ growth trajectories often exhibit a steady trajectory much like the arctic explorer Anderson’s concept of marching 20 miles every day to the South Pole to be Cpt Scott , regardless of whether the weather was good or bad
  • Adopting such a ‘20 Mile March’ will require pushing hard in adversity and reign it in during good times
  • Such a philosophy will increase confidence because the organisation will be able to achieve results regardless of conditions
  • Conversely, it is not about growing as quickly as possible all the time. Indeed, the study found that there is an inverse relationship between pursuit of maximum growth and 10x success. Growing too quickly can often lead to companies over extending themselves.

Concept: Fire Bullets, Then Cannonballs

  • 10xers use low-risk empirical tests (‘firing bullets’) to validate what ideas work.
  • Only once a company has successfully tested an idea with bullets should they fire the ‘cannonball’
  • 10xers are therefore not visionary geniuses but empiricists.
  • Acquisitions can qualify as bullets if they’re low-cost, low-risk and low-distraction

Concept: Leading above the Death Line

  • 10xers effectively identify and manage risk
  • When risks are identified these companies spend significant time and energy on understanding the likely impact through empirical analysis and then working very hard to execute their risk mitigation plan

Concept: SMaC

  • 10xers have a Specific, Methodical and Consistent (“SMaC”) recipe that they adhered to
  • SmaC recipes endured for the long term and were changed by an average of 15% over the era of analysis
  • See South Western airline’s SMaC in the book as a good example

Concept: Return on Luck

  • All companies have good and bad luck. 10xers had their fair share of both
  • The rest of the concepts above must be enthusiastically executed well to get a good return on luck

Could a Yorkshire perspective improve this book?

Well the examples could be more global and less USA centric, but that does not make them less effective for illustrating the point.

Review Takeaway:

The concept of growth without over extension is a very powerful take away. Yorkshire Powerhouse, Book reviews

Click here for a quick link to purchase Great by Choice from Amazon

Have you any questions?

Here at Yorkshire Powerhouse, we’re happy to help as much as possible – is there anything else we can do to help you, do you have any further questions or can we help introduce you to an expert – please let us know:

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


Starting a business

Starting a business – A guide to a successful launch

When starting a business, be obsessed with perfection and control. Invest and do it right from the start and your business will reflect your approach.



Marketing really should be at the core of your business strategy – marketing leads to sales and without sales you really have no business!

The GREAT Yorkshire Directory
Powerhouse Networking

The GREAT Yorkshire Suppliers Directory:

Here are some more of our GREAT suppliers who can help your business:

Do you need some FREE planning tools to help your business?

Take a look at our download files by clicking this link ...

Would you like to receive more FREE business information?

Recieve our FREE email newsletter...
...just enter your email address here:

You have Successfully Subscribed!